Credential Stuffing: The Silent Epidemic in the Age of Password Reuse

SWARNALI GHOSH | DATE: AUGUST 19, 2025

Introduction: A Digital Petri Dish of Weak Habits

Credential stuffing isn't a flashy cyber-attack—but its consequences are real, rapid, and often invisible. In a world where recycled passwords are so commonplace, hackers leverage automated tools and stolen credentials to quietly infiltrate countless accounts. The result: A silent epidemic born from human convenience—and amplified by bot efficiency.

What Is Credential Stuffing—and Why It Works

At its core, credential stuffing is an automated replay attack: stolen username-password pairs from one breach are fed into other services in hopes of finding a match. This succeeds largely because password reuse is rampant—one source reports 81% of users reuse passwords across at least two sites, and 25% reuse the same password for most of their accounts. With tools like Selenium, OpenBullet, Sentry MBA, and voluminous “combo lists,” attackers attempt logins rapidly and at scale. Cybercriminals rely on automation platforms such as Selenium and credential-testing kits like OpenBullet or Sentry MBA, along with massive databases of stolen username-password combinations, to launch large-scale login attempts at high speed. With a success rate ranging from 0.1% to 2%, every million attempts can yield upwards of 20,000 compromised accounts.

A Growing Crisis Fueled by Data Leaks and Automation

Breach Fuel: Mountains of Stolen Credentials: A study found 15 billion stolen login records from around 100,000 breaches. In June 2025 alone, 16 billion credentials were exposed across 33 major incidents. According to Cybernews, an analysis of 19 billion exposed passwords collected between April 2024 and April 2025 revealed that just 6% were distinct, while a staggering 94% had been reused across multiple accounts.

Automation Makes It Cheap and Easy: Attackers buy combo lists for pennies and employ bots, proxies, and CAPTCHA-solving services to mimic human behaviour and evade defences. One report from ID Dataweb reveals a 50% increase in monthly credential stuffing attempts,

26 billion attempts per month.

Hard to Detect, Easy to Exploit: Because these attacks leverage legitimate credentials, they often slip past traditional security measures. Bots mimic human-like patterns, evading rate limits and raising no alarms.

Real-World Impact: Financial & Data Fallout

Financial Losses Run Deep: Breaches linked to credential stuffing incidents carry a heavy financial toll, with the typical cost reaching as high as 4.81 million U.S. dollars. Regulatory bodies like Australia’s APRA reported specific losses—for instance, AustralianSuper lost AUD 750,000 across several member accounts.

Catastrophic Breaches: An academic study revealed how reusing passwords in the breach of 23andMe in October 2023 led to the compromise of 5.5 million users, exposing genetic and personal data. Cybercriminals rely on automation platforms such as Selenium and credential-testing kits like OpenBullet or Sentry MBA, along with massive databases of stolen username-password combinations, to launch large-scale login attempts at high speed.

Chain Reaction Breaches: With so many credentials out there, one breach often seeds attacks across multiple platforms in a cyber-domino effect.

Why It's Still Rampant

Low technical bar, high yield: Attack tools and stolen credentials are cheap and accessible.

Slow detection timelines: On average, it takes organisations about 204 days to detect a breach caused by stolen credentials and an additional 73 days to fully contain it.

Credential phishing & infostealers: These fuel fresh credential dumps; phishing-delivered infostealers rose dramatically, leading to identity-based breaches accounting for 30% of intrusions.

Combating Credential Stuffing: Building a Secure Future

For Users:

1. Use unique, strong passwords (ideally with a password manager).

2. Activate multi-factor authentication (MFA) or passkeys.

3. Check if your credentials appear in breaches and update compromised passwords promptly.

For Organisations: Layers of Defence

A robust defence-in-depth approach includes:

Credential Screening at Sign-up/Login: Block or reset accounts using previously breached credentials (e.g., via “EmailAge” risk scoring).

Adaptive MFA and Passkeys: Enforce additional verification only when needed; passkeys offer phishing resistance and seamless UX.

Bot Mitigation and Detection: Fingerprint sessions, throttle rapid attempts, and deploy invisible challenges to disrupt automated attacks.

Continuous Session Monitoring: Watch for anomalies like impossible travel or escalation attempts, then terminate malicious sessions instantly.

Identity Threat Detection & Response (ITDR): Leverage AI and behaviour analytics to detect credential abuse or identity attacks proactively.

Emerging Tech: Passkeys everywhere (FIDO2) reduce risk by making stolen passwords worthless. Browser attestation and invisible risk signals help verify trusted environments. AI-driven fraud prediction can anticipate attack spikes and pre-emptively tighten defences.

The Human Factor: Culture and Awareness

Strong technology isn't enough if password culture doesn't evolve. Research indicates that password reuse isn’t just a problem among everyday users—an estimated 92% of IT executives acknowledge repeating passwords across accounts. Public awareness campaigns and transparent breach notifications can shift the user mindset. After all, the weakest link often

isn't the tool—but us.

Conclusion: Credential Stuffing—A Quiet Epidemic That Demands Our Attention

Credential stuffing is deceptively simple yet devastatingly effective. In an age defined by password reuse, attackers exploit human habits with the cold efficiency of bots. It's time for users, businesses, and regulators alike to treat this “silent epidemic” as the urgent crisis it is. For individuals: treat each password like a key—unique, strong, and never duplicated. For organisations: build layered, intelligent defences that disrupt automation without hindering legitimate users. Because in the digital age, security isn’t just about prevention—it’s about culture, vigilance, and evolving with the threat. Credential stuffing won’t vanish overnight, but with concerted effort, it can finally be contained.

Citations/References

1. What is Credential Stuffing? | CrowdStrike. (n.d.). https://www.crowdstrike.com/en-us/cybersecurity-101/cyberattacks/credential-stuffing/

2. Credential stuffing | OWASP Foundation. (n.d.). https://owasp.org/www-community/attacks/Credential_stuffing

3. IBM X-Force 2025 Threat Intelligence Index. (2025, April 16). IBM. https://www.ibm.com/thought-leadership/institute-business-value/en-us/report/2025-threat-intelligence-index

4. Gardner, A., & Human. (2025, March 18). Credential stuffing and account takeover attacks remain nagging business problems. HUMAN Security. https://www.humansecurity.com/learn/blog/credential-stuffing-and-account-takeover-attacks-remain-nagging-business-problems/

5. Dataweb, T. I. (2025, April 21). How to secure yourself from credential stuffing account takeovers in 2025. ID Dataweb. https://www.iddataweb.com/credential-stuffing-attacks/

6. The rise of credential compromise attacks | Fortinet. (n.d.). Fortinet. https://www.fortinet.com/resources/articles/credential-compromise-attacks

7. Governance, I. (2025, August 12). Global Data Breaches and Cyber Attacks in June 2025: Over 16 billion records exposed. IT Governance Blog. https://www.itgovernance.co.uk/blog/global-data-breaches-and-cyber-attacks-in-june-2025-over-16-billion-records-exposed

8. Understanding credential stuffing and how to prevent it | Spec. (n.d.). https://www.specprotected.com/blog/credential-stuffing-prevention

9. Enzoic. (2025, May 7). The consequences of password reuse. Enzoic. https://www.enzoic.com/blog/the-consequences-of-password-reuse/

10. Exabeam. (2025, July 17). How credential attacks work and 5 defensive Measures [2025 Guide]. https://www.exabeam.com/explainers/insider-threats/how-credential-attacks-work-and-5-defensive-measures/

11. Alder, S. (2024, January 31). 92% of IT leaders are guilty of password reuse. The HIPAA Journal. https://www.hipaajournal.com/92-of-it-leaders-guilty-of-password-reuse/

Image Citations

1. Egs (2021, May 19). What is credential stuffing, and how does it work? EC-Council Global Services (EGS). https://egs.eccouncil.org/what-is-credential-stuffing-and-how-does-it-work/

2. The Hacker News. (n.d.). Are you willing to pay the high cost of compromised credentials? https://thehackernews.com/2023/09/are-you-willing-to-pay-high-cost-of.html

3. Dashlane. (2023, November 14). What is credential stuffing and how can it impact you? | Dashlane. Dashlane. https://www.dashlane.com/blog/what-credential-stuffing-is

4. Chinnasamy, V. (2025, July 11). How to stop credential stuffing attacks? | Indusface blog. Indusface. https://www.indusface.com/blog/credential-stuffing-prevention-how-to-stop-and-mitigate-credential-stuffing-attacks/

5. Brown, A. (2023, October 27). What is Credential Stuffing? - Transmit Security. Transmit Security. https://transmitsecurity.com/blog/credential-stuffing

6. Credential Stuffing 101: What it is and how to prevent it. (2025, April 17). wiz.io. https://www.wiz.io/academy/credential-stuffing